A sad coincidence

20 December 2025

On 19 August 1864 the Confederate Conscription Bureau in Richmond, VA sent a notice to the Army’s Adjutant General that Private J.H. Garrison was considered a deserter from Company B of Cobb’s Legion Infantry Battalion and was thought to be in the 14th Texas. The Bureau had no direct authority to return a soldier to his regiment, so sent the notice to General Cooper for action.

On the same day, about 500 miles away in Atlanta, GA, then Quartermaster Sergeant John H. Garrison of the 14th Texas Cavalry was killed by enemy artillery during the siege of that city.

Late of Rusk County, TX, Garrison had enlisted in Cobb’s Legion in Bowdon, GA in July 1861, was wounded on the Maryland Campaign of September 1862, and was sent home on wounded furlough by that November. In January 1863 he enlisted in Rusk County in the 14th Texas Cavalry, and was detailed to assist his brother Zed, the regiment’s Quartermaster. Both men were in Atlanta looking for clothing when John was killed.

On about 8 October 1864 that notice reached senior Captain N.S. Allen, then the commanding officer of the 14th Texas Infantry, who replied that there was no one of that name in his unit …


Notes

That document is among John Garrison’s Compiled Service Records at the National Archives. I got my copy online from fold3. Here’s my transcription of it:

Confederate States of America,
War Department,
Bureau of Conscription,
Richmond, Va. Aug 19th 1864

[to]
General S. Cooper,
Adjutant and Inspector General:

General:

Private J.H. Garrison has been reported to this Bureau as a deserter from Company B, Cobbs Legion Infty Regiment, with the information that he will be found in Company ___, 14th Texas Regiment.

This Bureau not having the authority to order his return to his original command, the case is respectfully referred for your information.

Very respectfully,
Your obedient servant,

[signature] L P August [?]
Col Actg Superintendent

Son of a prosperous planter, John N Henderson was 18 years old in July 1861 when he enlisted as a Private in Company E of the 5th Texas Infantry in Washington, TX. He was not yet 20 when he was shot in the left arm in combat at Sharpsburg on 17 September 1862. He lost his arm above the elbow to amputation and was sent home, disabled for further field service.

In October 1864 Brigadier General J.B. Robertson, commanding state reserve troops in Texas, appointed John to his staff as a Captain and Aide-de-Camp; the uniform he’s wearing above.

After the war Henderson was a successful lawyer, district attorney, state senator, and judge in Texas. Here he is in about 1868 with his first wife, the former Hester Hubert:


Notes

Both of these excellent photographs [top, below] are online in the Tennessee Virtual Archives collection. There are at least two more photos of John in that collection: one taken at about the time he enlisted in 1861 and one dating from about 1894, when he was appointed a judge on the Texas Court of Appeals in Austin.

Three Irish-born McClure brothers of White County, Georgia, who served together in Company K of the 24th Georgia Infantry during the war:

James Samuel (1828-1907), at left, may have been with his company in Maryland in September 1862, but departed, sick with typhoid, in October, and spent much of the rest of the war in hospitals.

Thomas Henry (1840-1900), at the right, was probably at Sharpsburg, and was captured at Gettysburg in July 1863 and a prisoner to the end of the war.

In the middle is the youngest, Samuel D McClure (1842-1862), who was 3rd Sergeant of the company when he was killed at Sharpsburg on 17 September 1862.


Notes

This lovely photograph was contributed to Samuel’s Findagrave memorial by relatives in the Taylor family.

Some references suggest that the 4th McClure brother, Robert (1832-1923), also served in Company K, but I did not find him in the Compiled Service Records for the unit or in Henderson’s Roster.